An Educational Culture: The Right Angle on Education

Posted on March 3, 2015 by Dr. Gary L. Welton

Font:

The basic problem with America’s educational system is not that college is too expensive. Nor is the basic problem that public school teachers are underpaid or that educators are poorly trained. The basic problem with America’s educational system today is that far too many children are given the implicit message at home that education is not a priority. “Perhaps the nerds and the geeks need these educational skills, but in our home, they just are not that important.”

Our schools face a huge challenge today, because the educational message that teachers are trying to inculcate into their students is far too often dismissed at home. If you live in a subculture where education is not valued, it is unlikely you will come to value your own educational opportunities. We cannot expect our schools to inculcate values of learning when there is little to no reinforcement at home.

The reality of life is that education and learning is not always fun. I was, and still am, an eager learner; nevertheless, some topics were uninteresting and seemed pointless when I first learned them. Some things are not intuitive; being sick and missing math class the day we were introduced to right angles, I was totally confused the day I returned to school. I could not figure out whether a right angle was the opposite of a left angle or the opposite of a wrong angle. That, of course, was an easy fix with a few questions that evening around the dinner table—an easy fix because my parents and my older siblings cared about education.

The college opportunity was not available to my father-in-law, but one of his primary goals in life was to enable his children to be college graduates. In order to fund this educational goal, he worked a factory job in addition to farming his own property. He only liked one of these jobs, but he worked them both, because he wanted to make sure his children had every educational opportunity. In “Look Homeward, Angel,” Thomas Wolfe says, “He loved a farm better than anything in the world except a school.” My father-in-law communicated that value to his children.

My father-in-law saw both of his children succeed in college, and recently celebrated the diplomas of all four of his grandchildren. He fostered an educational culture in which education was important. His children and grandchildren were motivated by his own continuing love of learning.

President Obama has sought to increase the number of college graduates in America, and is currently proposing that the federal and state governments pay the tuition for community college students. As Michael Horn recently stated in a CNN column, however, community colleges have not been particularly successful (only 22 percent of students complete their two-year degree within three years and 28 percent within four years), in spite of the fact that tuition is already heavily subsidized. He concludes that 60 percent of tuition is already covered by federal, state, and local programs, and, for needy students, the remaining 40 percent is entirely covered by Pell Grants.

Horn argues that providing free tuition will not fix the educational system. Indeed, the problem begins in American homes. When parents and caregivers communicate that education provides access to jobs and opportunities, and when parents demonstrate that college tuition is high on their list of priorities, students will come to value their educational opportunities. President Obama’s current proposal will not fix the problem unless the core issue of educational value becomes the focus.

If we want to improve our educational system, creating an educational culture is the essential and right angle.

Dr. Gary L. Welton

Dr. Gary L. Welton is assistant dean for institutional assessment, professor of psychology at Grove City College, and a contributor to The Center for Vision & Values. He is a recipient of a major research grant from the Templeton Foundation to investigate positive youth development.

32 responses to “An Educational Culture: The Right Angle on Education”

  1. TheLookOut says:

    Excellent article that hits the truth head on. Our educational system is
    very flawed as education is not valued because it's too free. Many
    have no investment in their child's education. They dump the kids
    on the schools, and teachers to rear, and educate, and of course
    play the blame game when the kid gets in trouble robbing the 7-11.

  2. Dad says:

    I disagree with your premise Mr. Ringer "The basic problem with America’s educational system today is that far too many children are given the implicit message at home that education is not a priority."

    I am a huge advocate of education but not necessarily traditional education. Being that we are n the information age we can learn pretty much anything we want in an afternoon to a few weeks.

    The problem I see is that there is so much emphases on traditional education that has not been retooled for the 21st century. We cannot keep going down the 20th century road in education and not take into consideration that the business community is in the 21st century.

    We hear all the time about how important it is to go on a get a College degree and here we are with the next financial bubble to burst will be the student loan bubble. And back in the real world most students cannot find substantial work to repay those loans.

    Meanwhile in the private sector at this point in time (Pre FCC Lockdown) people are able to start a business
    online for very little money and be very successful. Do you think you need a College degree to start an online business?

    The problem with Education is first, the intrusion of the Department of Education, before it's inception we had a 3% illiteracy rate, today after billions has been spent we have a 19% illiteracy rate. Second is kids that are not college material get brainwashed and think negatively of them self if they don't go get that degree.

    You know as well as I do that the most successful people in history rarely had any college education, they just out there and made it happen and they are the people that hire the people that got the college education.

    Again, good article but I don't necessarily agree

    • Grant says:

      I think the point was: a self-motivated "student" will succeed one way or another if supported, enabled & encouraged at home. Absent that, all else is futile.

  3. mike says:

    I disagree. College is too expensive. Also since resumes are still in use, college degrees and diplomas still hold a prominent place on them to get a job in the states. Self made entrepreneurs do have an advantage. They did learn 'how to think and reason' to decide that self employment was the best way to go, which is why education is so important, regardless or whether or not education is a priority in the home. So it may not be a priority in some homes to their detriment. I didn't like this article.

    • Robert Robert says:

      I think you missed the point. The major issue here is the home environment. If parents do not value education they will not teach their children to value education.
      How do you treat things you do not value?
      Welcome to a teachers nightmare……
      If you have any doubts check into the parents who have gang members for children, check in with mothers who have children for the sake of collecting money from the government (hmm sex for money sounds like prostitution to me, but that is another issue)

    • Grant says:

      College is only "too expensive" for those that seek "credentials" in low paying (or fully meaningless) fields of study. That said, a motivated student in auto body repair or custom motorcycle fabrication is more-than-less valuable to our economy as a motivated student in any other meaningful field.

  4. Marte says:

    I don't agree either. College is not the answer for everyone, but learning to read, write, and do basic math IS important for everyone. So is learning history.

    And yet… schools are failing to teach these important skills.

    Yes, children do need parental support and do need to learn that education is important. But if the parents aren't capable of teaching those basics, they need teachers who are doing the job.

    When a 4th grade teacher writes a letter to the editor that begins "When myself and my friends…" you know the kids are in trouble.

  5. Terence Verma says:

    Clearly we need to make the difference between an 'education' to become academically bright and that which prepares one to face the real world. Working for someone else's dream requires the degrees and such like…a filtering. Working to fulfil your own dreams needs a different kind of approach to learning. Albeit, Marte's point about knowing how to read, write and do basic math is important.

  6. larajf says:

    I like how people are reading and thinking through your essay, Dr. Welton. I'm not sure I agree with the premise precisely. I do think people don't value education, but I think it's because of the "everyone's a winner" mentality. The perception is that no matter what effort you put in, you'll get your diploma and a job, even if that's not reality. Everyone thinks they'll get a super high paying job because they deserve it. No one is placing value on education or the actual work involved, unfortunately.

  7. boundedfunction says:

    the damage is done long before college age arrives. & the affliction predates, by many generations, all weighing in now. for history of prussian schooling/conditioning concepts, who brought them to amerika & why, see john taylor gatto. for beautiful writing on education – & educability – see albert j. nock.

    education is a good, if, & only if, educability is present. “education” is something else entirely: a massively tax subsidized cartel. a bait & switch “magic” show. a part of the “american dream” pitch right up there with home ownership as an investment, social security, exceptionalism & equality. you might notice the odor of that last one, wafting thru the essay above.

    the educable are, or strongly tend to be, students before “educators” ever get their paychecks out of them (which is a turn of phrase, since paychecks are cut despite the students…students, like patients, are not customers, they are but consumption for the cartel). & they continue to be students throughout their lives. the “educated” matriculate, get the docs signifying “made” status, & they’re done (in truth, again, they were done before they ever hit a campus). training is not education. a trained seal is not an educated seal, & ringing bells eliciting movement, of “students”, or of saliva, is not education. it is conditioning.

    • boundedfunction says:

      besides the glare coming off apologias for “education” by those who derive their livelihood from the cartel (“the basic problem…is not that college is too expensive…[is not] that public school teachers are underpaid or…poorly trained”), & the blaming of the would-be victims that get in the way of 100% “educated” stats, watch out for “templeton foundation grants”.

      on the one hand, john templeton was an impressive individual who made a lot of $, honestly & by his own lights (akaik), renounced amerikan citizenship in ’64 so as to keep more of his production, & split for the bahamas…all good.

      otoh, he’s funded some red & false flags, like “positive psychology” (& the raft of academic cartelistas who are making careers out of it), that feed right back into the dreaming. since these “philanthropies” came nearer the end of his life, maybe senility & dementia explain. but, there’s also yale, elihu, oxford/rhodes scholarship (do look into cecil rhodes, while you’re at it), all of which were nearer the beginning. those sorts of beginnings feature prominently in gatto’s history.

      & the answer to the titular question, “do androids, amerikan & otherwise, dream of electric sheep?” is yes. because an “educated” android is really just a sheep who has paid to have his own wool pulled over. ☻

  8. Gordon says:

    We need to be very clear about the difference between education and credentials. A college degree is a credential, education is what we learn. Sometimes there is a close correlation between the two, and sometimes hardly any correlation at all. Today, anyone, ANYONE, who wants to learn and has an internet connection can learn almost anything they want, taught by some of the best teachers/professors in the world. But unless they go through the expensive process of attending an authorized university, they will lack the credentials that are necessary for the degree that employers demand. At some point this has to change, but it will require dramatic changes, perhaps even revolutions, in several regimes.

    My parents both taught at the middle school/high school level, and tried to be good teachers. I heard lots of stories. But the system is designed to protect the vested interests, and real education is just an accidental byproduct that results from individual teachers who are really motivated by the desire to teach, despite the obstacles they face and the lack of interest in anything but protecting the status quo from politicians, administrators, and too often even parents. I honor those who do their best, despite the obstacles, but I despise the system as it currently exists.

  9. Paul Anthony says:

    I've read some very astute comments here, and am encouraged by the depth of understanding exhibited by the posters.

    A degree is something to be added to a resume. It does not prove that one has knowledge, let alone wisdom, but has become a requirement for employment in corporate and public sector work. Fortunately, some small employers take the time to interview applicants. Such companies acquire the best and brightest.

    I became disillusioned with formal education quickly. After sitting through boring classes, I decided to skip the enrollment process and just buy the text books. This allowed me to learn at a much quicker pace. If a subject interests me, I will devour all the information I can find. But, if I'm not interested, sitting through lectures for a semester will teach me nothing.

    As a result, I never found the time to attend college – I've always been too busy learning!

  10. Stephan F says:

    "The basic problem with America’s educational system today is that far too many children are given the implicit message at home that education is not a priority."

    Huh? Surely, doctor, you jest… So, of all the endless & life draining problems associated with public education, this is your explanation of what is causing the abject & utter failure of one of the most disastrous human experiments ever attempted? Roberrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrt!

  11. psychicmindvandervoort231 says:

    First, distinguish between "education" and "training". An engineer is not necessarily "educated", but s'he is trained. We know what "training" is, but few seem to know what it means to be "educated".

  12. greg says:

    This is the first article I did not like from you. Maybe I'm just not educated enough to understand the validity of your point although I was extremely successful getting most of my education in the schools of hard knocks.

  13. Lee Delbridge says:

    Each person should have a good "general" education and then be well educated in their area of "giftedness" and interest.

  14. Jim Hallett says:

    What is amazing is that so many people survive the horrid public education system to have success at all! Having encouragement & support from parents, grandparents, etc. is crucial (look at how well Asians do with education where it is valued at home vs. other groups where it is not), but I do believe one's curiosity and thirst for knowledge needs to come from within, and is totally irrelevant to what an institutional piece of paper says. I would like to see apprenticeship come back as well for those who have no interest in college, and I think with the plethora of info available on the internet, college attendance is in for some major drops in the years ahead.

  15. Peggy says:

    I couldn't agree more with this article! And the sorry public school system accommodates these kids which is what caused me to pull my child out to homeschool her. A classmate lived in a 40 year old trailer on a leased lot with two generations of people in it. But hey, she was packing an iphone cuz they had their priorities straight. She'd likely never seen the inside of a library. She spent a lot of time babysitting her little brother while divorced mom was out cavorting with her new boyfriend who had four kids of his own. Schoolwork had no priority to either this girl or her mom. Education is absolutely fostered in the home. My child's ipod is mine from Sunday at 4:00 til Friday at 4:00.

  16. Daniel says:

    My mom used to say, "It takes two to tango." A family environment which nurtures the notion that education is essential, combined with an educational system in which all elements are committed to excellence, will produce excellent results: well-educated, well-rounded adults. If one, the other, or both are dysfunctional… The result is obvious, and tragic.

  17. Njuguna says:

    The other day i was thinking how some people make fun of theres and label them as "geeks" or "nerds"..yet they dont realise that were it not for those nerds, they would not be showing off their latest iPhones and even using the internet! My two cents…Gerald of http://learnershipsa.com

  18. Jean says:

    "The basic problem with America’s educational system today is that far too many children are given the implicit message at home that education is not a priority. " Really? Or is it that today, education is less about developing innate talent and skill so that a child can function effectively in the real world and more about indoctrinating that child to embrace a particular ideological viewpoint without question? I have termed today's college students – millennials – the Bubble Wrap generation, because they've rarely been called upon to use any critical thinking skills, have very few genuinely marketable skills and can't handle stress of any kind. Evidence is abundant, but was most recently discovered by a New York Times editorialist: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/22/opinion/sunday/

  19. Frank L says:

    Ahaha, when you can't write any good you fall into depression. That sounds like a plan to me! Jokes aside, help required. Don't hurry with running to the doctor. Once breezewriting write my speech and I know they can write much more than that. They provide excellent help with any kinds of writings. You may need a small kick from them to get you out of depression!

  20. sahil says:

    Get all HPE0-S46 practice test resources and tools including dumps pdf, self-test software, and questions and answers for all the HP certification exams prepared and designed exclusively by qualified body of professionals and experts. Pass your exam with our HPE0-S46 cert practice test.

  21. Kelly says:

    The most effortless advantages to call attention to are the instructive devices of space, relationship and extents, all of which will enhance math mindfulness aptitudes. Fun time playing with Legos shows parts and wholes, contingent upon the pieces being utilized. Quarter pieces are likewise accessible, and keeping in online coursework help mind that children don't allude to them by that name, they are learning division hypothesis pleasantly! Points must be considered too when building, which is additionally adapted experientially through experimentation as children play with Legos and have the chance to make.

  22. Kelly says:

    The most effortless advantages to call attention to are the instructive devices of space, relationship and extents, all of which will enhance math mindfulness aptitudes. Fun time playing with Legos shows parts and wholes, contingent upon the pieces being utilized. Quarter pieces are likewise accessible, and keeping in http://www.pro-academic.co.uk/coursework-writing-… mind that children don't allude to them by that name, they are learning division hypothesis pleasantly! Points must be considered too when building, which is additionally adapted experientially through experimentation as children play with Legos and have the chance to make.

  23. ivanhamlin says:

    The basic problem with America’s educational system is not that college is too expensive. Nor is the basic problem that public school teachers are underpaid or that educators are poorly trained. The basic problem with America’s educational system today is that the dissertation help service far too many children are given the implicit message at home that education is not a priority. “Perhaps the nerds and the geeks need these educational skills, but in our home, they just are not that important.”

  24. Allen says:

    That, of course, was an easy fix with a few questions that evening around the dinner table—an easy fix because my parents and my older siblings cared about education. Cisco CCNP 300-115 VCE

  25. John says:

    The huge challenge today is to make all the people of the world become literate. This is the first and most valuable question. https://narrativeessays.org/ blog would help to all in this question.

  26. gopcongress says:

    First, let's be clear: College is, currently, NOT a place of "higher learning" as it is a case of "advanced socialist indoctrination," coupled with a huge money grab through high tuition fees paid for by "student loans."

    Once you understand this premise, one realizes that the absolute FIRST thing that needs to change is the entire administration, politicization, and frankly, anti-American corruption that our "institutions of higher learning" spew out. Once we get this behemoth under control (Betsy DeVos, do your thing!), then we can start with defining literacy.

    Of course, K-12 needs to greatly change its political corruption as well. Parents need to start looking for alternatives to the abusive school boards that push a political narrative over education. The more politically indoctrinated school districts are, the more likely that the literacy and mathematical knowledge level are deficient in the students who suffer through those districts.

  27. sophie says:

    Robert, you inspire so many! Thank you for your diligent, enlightening, good news. Keep it rolling! net worth